Buying a mattress is a big deal—it’s the foundation of your sleep for years to come, so getting to know the best mattresses should be the first step when choosing a new mattress. The experts have gotten to work for you and tested several top mattress brands, and they’ll share their experiences ahead. As professional mattress testing editors have noted, there’s a model for everyone. Find out what they liked about these mattresses and what (if anything) they were missing.
The DreamCloud Hybrid Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What distinguishes this mattress brand in your eyes? The exceptional delivery process stands out, making setup effortlessly seamless. Witnessing the simplicity of installation, I shared this experience with a friend who was in the market for a new mattress. Even before he tested its quality by lying down, he was already navigating the website to place an order. Such is the impact of the hassle-free delivery and straightforward setup.
What do you cherish about this mattress? My childhood sleeping experience was confined to a twin mattress, which didn’t provide the best comfort. However, DreamCloud elevates twin-mattress comfort to new heights. It’s not just the way my body feels when I recline on it; it’s also the luxurious touch of the mattress itself. It exudes an air of opulence, yet it comes at an affordable price.
If you could make one alteration, what would it be? My suggestion wouldn’t concern the mattress itself but rather the shipping process. While this might be a lofty request (likely why it’s not offered), I would gladly pay extra for an option where DreamCloud could arrange the removal of my old mattress.
How does this mattress compare to your previous sleep experiences? Among twin mattresses, this one ranks as the finest I’ve ever slept on. The only comparable competitor is Nectar.
The Nectar Memory Foam Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What makes this mattress brand stand out to you? Ordering from Nectar was a seamless experience, especially during a hectic move. Their customer service ensured my mattress reached the correct address at the right time. Additionally, when purchasing directly from Nectar, they often include complimentary pillows, bed sheets, and a mattress protector with your order. One of the standout advantages of choosing Nectar is their extraordinary warranty – a lifetime guarantee, surpassing the typical 10 to 20-year warranties offered by most brands. Moreover, Nectar provides an extensive 365-day sleep trial, far beyond the industry-standard 100 nights.
What are the aspects of this mattress that you adore? Nectar’s mattress is a dream for all types of sleepers. It delivers exceptional support while maintaining a luxurious level of comfort. Climbing into bed each night feels like sinking into a cloud. For those sharing a bed with restless sleepers, this mattress is a godsend. It virtually eliminates disturbances caused by your sleeping partner’s movements. As far as memory foam mattresses go, it’s the best I’ve encountered, ensuring peaceful sleep regardless of external disruptions.
If there was one thing you could alter about it, what would it be? Occasionally, the Nectar mattress can feel a bit warm on certain nights, despite the presence of heat-wicking, cooling technology on the top layer. It’s worth noting that most memory foam beds tend to retain more heat than traditional mattresses. However, this minor inconvenience is a small trade-off for the overall comfort the mattress provides. Utilizing the Nectar sheet set that comes free with the mattress helps in keeping the temperature cool.
How does this mattress compare to other mattresses you’ve experienced? Prior to upgrading to the Nectar Memory Foam mattress, I endured restless nights on a budget mattress I purchased post-college, which took a toll on my back. That old mattress felt like it aged me prematurely. After just a few nights on the new Nectar mattress, my lower back pain miraculously vanished. Disposing of that aging spring-filled relic was one of the wisest decisions I’ve made.
Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What distinguishes Helix Sleep as a mattress brand for you? Helix Sleep stands out due to its attentive response to customer feedback and its ongoing enhancements to their already exceptional mattresses. The most recent iteration, the Helix Midnight Luxe, is nothing short of a dream!
What are your favorite features of this mattress? My sleeping habits require a hybrid mattress that accommodates my need for temperature regulation, minimal motion transfer, and crucial lumbar support for my back and neck. While memory foam mattresses are trendy, I’m quite particular, seeking that ideal balance – not too soft or too firm, not too warm or too cold. The Helix Midnight Luxe, in essence, offers the perfect balance.
How does this mattress stack up against others you’ve tried? The Helix Midnight Luxe sets the standard for mattress luxury. While you can find similar qualities in the Allswell Supreme or the Leesa Hybrid, the Helix Midnight Luxe reigns supreme. It’s the epitome of opulence, the pièce de résistance, the mattress to surpass all others.
Would you consider purchasing from this mattress brand again? Without a doubt. Especially knowing Helix’s dedication to scientific precision in crafting their products. Much like a fine wine, these mattresses are bound to only improve with time.
Birch Natural Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets apart this mattress brand for you? The Birch mattress brand caught my attention due to its strong commitment to eco-friendliness. Birch’s products are entirely devoid of polyurethane-based foams and harsh chemicals. I’m always on the lookout for mattress companies that prioritize sustainably sourced materials and practices.
What do you admire about this mattress? To begin with, this mattress boasts an elegant appearance. The intricate details in its color and materials made it immediately stand out upon arrival. It strikes the perfect balance between firmness and softness, offering a comfortable sleeping experience without feeling overly rigid or overly plush – it’s truly a Goldilocks-level perfection.
How does this mattress stack up against other mattresses you’ve tried? I find that its construction exudes a focus on quality. It feels notably more durable than several other mattresses I’ve purchased and slept on in the past.
Floyd Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? This particular mattress surprised me with its substantial weight, and as it turns out, that’s a noteworthy aspect. The weight translates to exceptional support and comfort, making it one of the finest mattresses I’ve ever owned.
What do you appreciate about this mattress? Evidently, the superb support it provides stems from its 1,000 pocketed coils, offering precise “zoned support.” I also admire the incredibly soft Tencel top cover, crafted from eco-friendly wood pulp, and the effective temperature regulation it offers. While the mattress’s bottom features a non-skid knit to prevent slipping on the base, the inclusion of handles on the sides proves to be quite practical for repositioning when necessary.
If you could make any changes to it, what would they be? The mattress’s weight can pose a challenge when moving it, but I wouldn’t want to compromise its structural integrity.
How does this mattress compare to others you’ve experienced? It seems that this mattress is built to last, which isn’t always the case with other mattresses that come conveniently packaged in a box.
Casper Wave Hybrid Snow Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? Casper is a brand with a well-established reputation, and it’s a name that I’ve heard praised by both friends and acquaintances. I’ve personally experienced the comfort of Casper mattresses, and their long-standing presence in the mattress-in-a-box market gives them a sense of reliability and trustworthiness.
What do you appreciate about this mattress? Casper has introduced an innovative solution to a common sleep problem – overheating. They’ve developed a unique technology called Airscape, which incorporates various layers and foams to create a mattress that can feel up to six degrees cooler than traditional models. I found this cooling airflow concept intriguing and refreshing, as it made me consider the overall comfort of my bed and mattress.
If you could make one improvement, what would it be? While the mattress itself is impressive, I believe there’s room for more prominent branding to highlight the innovative cooling technology. It would be beneficial for consumers to know about the unique features of the cooling mattress and whether there are ways for them to enhance this technology once it’s in their homes.
How does this mattress compare to others you’ve tried? The comfort of this mattress is exceptional. It strikes a perfect balance between firmness and body conformity, delivering a soothing and stable sleeping experience. During my time with the mattress, I felt cool – or at least, I didn’t experience overheating. Admittedly, I was in a relatively cool bedroom, but I’m confident that the mattress’s ability to dissipate body heat would hold up well over time.
Would you consider purchasing from this mattress brand again? Without a doubt, I would. The mattress provided excellent support, maintained its shape beautifully, and delivered a noticeable sense of cooler comfort.
Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What makes this mattress brand unique to you? Casper holds a special place as one of the pioneering mattress-in-a-box brands, and its established reputation in the industry carries a sense of trust and innovation. Casper’s consistent release of new products and models reflects its commitment to evolving with the times.
What are the standout features of this mattress that you appreciate? Initially, the aesthetics of this mattress catch the eye—its design, color, and material choices are all meticulously crafted. It strikes the perfect balance between firmness and plushness, achieving a Goldilocks-like level of comfort.
How does this mattress compare to your experiences with other mattresses? This mattress distinguishes itself by being notably softer and more cushiony compared to the other mattresses I’ve slept on recently. Its luxurious feel and comfort make it ideal for leisurely lounging, though for extended periods of nightly rest, it can sometimes border on being slightly too soft.
WinkBed Luxury Firm Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? In our quest for the perfect mattress, my partner and I had our hearts set on a firm, sumptuous model with a solid pillow top. After diligently scouring the mattress market for several months, we stumbled upon the WinkBed, a delightful hybrid creation that struck an ideal balance between firmness and plushness. Its hybrid construction was particularly appealing, as it provided comprehensive guidance on selecting the most suitable mattress for various sleep preferences.
What do you appreciate most about this mattress? The WinkBed’s hybrid design offers an exquisite fusion of attributes at a remarkably reasonable price point. Its cutting-edge mattress technology delivers robust edge support while efficiently dissipating excess heat, ensuring restful and serene nights of sleep. The affordability of this hybrid marvel in comparison to its counterparts in the market is truly noteworthy. Additionally, for those who may harbor reservations about purchasing a mattress online, WinkBed generously extends a 120-day warranty—a generous six-month sleep trial period! This ample duration allows ample time to ascertain the wisdom of one’s investment (in my case, it was a resounding success!).
If you could make one change, what would it be? Given the option available now, I would opt for the Plus mattress, specifically designed for individuals of greater weight, featuring the firmest configuration. I was pleasantly surprised by the remarkable comfort provided by the pillowtop and, despite my initial reluctance, I must confess that my partner and I fall into the category of “heavier people” in this particular scenario.
How does this mattress measure up against others you’ve experienced? As these mattresses are exclusively available for online purchase, I greatly appreciate the comprehensive customer journey that WinkBed offers, allowing for comparisons between Soft, Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus options, which makes the decision-making process exceedingly user-friendly.
Would you consider purchasing from this mattress brand again? Without a doubt, I would enthusiastically revisit WinkBed for future mattress acquisitions, especially given their provision of the firmest option, which caters wonderfully to those who relish the sensation of a firm bed.
Allswell Supreme Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? Allswell Home stands out by delivering exceptional quality at a remarkably affordable price point, which is a standout feature for me. My allegiance to Allswell extends to both my mattress and bed pillows.
What do you appreciate about this mattress? The Allswell Supreme mattress boasts an impressive blend of coils and memory foam, culminating in a sleep experience that is not only refreshingly cool but also offers a soothing embrace throughout the night. The integrated Euro-top is a delightful addition that elevates the entire mattress, imparting a sensation akin to resting on a fluffy cloud. It effectively cradles me while ensuring optimal temperature regulation and uninterrupted sleep.
How does this mattress compare to your previous experiences with other mattresses? I tend to be incredibly discerning when it comes to mattresses, perhaps akin to the legendary Princess and the Pea. Struggling with recurring backaches, I demand a firm, supportive foundation that also cocoons me in comfort. Furthermore, maintaining a cool sleeping environment is non-negotiable for me. After sampling over 30 mattresses, only a select few have come close to matching the Allswell Supreme’s performance. Notable mentions include the Helix Midnight Luxe and the Leesa Hybrid. If you seek a mattress that seamlessly combines robust support with temperature control, your options are indeed limited, and the winning formula often involves a hybrid design paired with the Slumbercloud Mattress Pad.
Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? Firstly, Saatva’s commitment to eco-friendliness is the standout feature that drew me to this mattress brand initially. Their mattress range offers various firmness levels and styles, but one that caught my attention was the Loom & Leaf model, which promises both body-cooling and pressure point relief.
What are the aspects you admire about this mattress? It stands out as the most breathable and comfortable mattress I’ve ever experienced. Additionally, its excellent motion isolation makes it ideal for light sleepers who want an uninterrupted night’s sleep.
Could you describe the installation process? Setting up this mattress was a breeze; I didn’t have to lift a finger except for indicating where I wanted it. Saatva offers a complimentary white-glove delivery service, taking care of all the arrangements. They even provide an option to dispose of your old mattress, although we didn’t require that service.
How would you characterize the mattress’s firmness? We specifically chose a firm mattress, and it lives up to its promise. My partner and I often joke about feeling like we’re floating on a sea of comfort when lying on it. There’s minimal sagging, and I believe it caters to various types of sleepers, including side, stomach, and back sleepers, due to its exceptional support.
Serta Arctic Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? Serta is a timeless mattress brand with a history dating back to its founding in 1931, offering a wealth of experience that surpasses many of the more recent DTC mattress brands.
How was the delivery experience? The delivery process was exceptionally smooth! The white glove service team was punctual, adhered to safety protocols by wearing masks, and efficiently set up the mattress while also removing the old one from the room.
What do you appreciate most about this mattress? Without a doubt, this mattress ranks among the most comfortable I’ve ever had the pleasure of sleeping on. It strikes a perfect balance between softness and support, exuding a remarkable sense of craftsmanship. Its cooling features, particularly the EverCool Fuze Gel Memory Foam, are truly exceptional. In fact, during colder nights, I added a mattress topper over the Arctic model to provide extra warmth. However, on warmer evenings, it performed admirably without any additional layers.
If there were one thing you could modify, what would it be? In terms of comfort and functionality, I wouldn’t change a thing. It’s worth noting that this mattress is slightly taller than many others on the market. Prospective buyers should consider this when assessing compatibility with existing bed frames and sheet sets.
Layla Hybrid Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What makes this mattress brand stand out to you? The Layla hybrid mattress caught my attention with its unique flippable feature, offering a choice between a soft and firm side. Additionally, I appreciate its gray covering, which gives it a sense of long-term cleanliness, at least in appearance. It’s worth noting that this mattress also comes with a 10-year warranty and a 120-night sleep trial.
What do you appreciate most about this mattress? This mattress has truly impressed me with its exceptional comfort. While I can’t yet vouch for its long-term durability, I was pleasantly surprised at how quickly my body adjusted to its comfort. My first night’s sleep was nothing short of wonderful, and every subsequent night has been consistently great.
If you could make one change, what would it be? If there’s anything I would consider changing, it wouldn’t be the mattress itself but rather the accompanying pillows. While they serve their purpose on my couch, I found them less suitable for sleeping.
How would you describe the firmness of the mattress? The mattress strikes a perfect balance for me. It’s firm enough to provide the support my back needs, yet it retains a soft and cradling feel. This is ideal for me since I prefer a softer mattress, but as I entered my 30s, I came to appreciate the benefits of a firmer mattress for my back health.
Tuft & Needle Original Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for you? This brand offers the quintessential “bed in a box” mattress experience, a true delight in my book. When I made the purchase, I distinctly remember yearning for an upgrade from my previous spring mattress. However, the direct-to-consumer mattresses featured in all of my cherished podcast advertisements remained just out of my financial reach. Tuft & Needle, on the other hand, expertly strikes a balance by providing a high-quality foam mattress at a more budget-friendly price point.
What do you admire about this mattress? I happen to be someone who greatly appreciates a firmer mattress. But when dealing with a traditional innerspring mattress, it simply fails to offer the desired contouring. My Tuft & Needle mattress beautifully combines a firm foam core that delivers the robust support I crave with a softer foam exterior that exhibits that memory foam sensation, which I find absolutely delightful.
If you could modify one aspect of it, what would it be? As a “hot sleeper,” I’ve encountered a common issue with many all-foam mattresses, which is their tendency to trap heat beneath you. Regrettably, my Tuft & Needle mattress initially exhibited this characteristic. However, I’m pleased to report that the T&N Original Mattress has since been enhanced with cooling gel and graphite within its layers, effectively addressing this concern. Additionally, the brand has introduced alternative mattress options, such as the Mint (slightly less firm with three foam layers compared to the original mattress’s two) and a hybrid mattress featuring a combination of foam and springs.
How does this mattress stack up against others you’ve slept on? My Tuft & Needle Original marks my inaugural experience with a consistently used foam mattress. With absolute certainty, I can attest that I hold it in much higher regard than any spring mattress I’ve ever slept on. Over time, spring mattresses tend to develop unevenness as the springs deteriorate from repetitive use. However, after nearly four years, my Tuft & Needle mattress remains as resilient and supportive as it did on the very first night. Furthermore, the absence of squeaks or jiggles when my feline companion returns from his midnight snack ensures an uninterrupted and sound REM cycle, making it an invaluable asset.
Leesa Studio Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets this mattress brand apart for me? Leesa stands as one of the trailblazers in the bed-in-a-box revolution, and their extensive experience in the mattress industry is evident in the exceptional quality of their products. Even after over a year of using my Leesa mattress, it maintains its original comfort and durability. This enduring quality speaks volumes about the brand’s dedication to excellence. Additionally, I admire Leesa’s philanthropic endeavors, particularly their One-Ten initiative, which donates one mattress to a family in need for every ten sold.
What do I cherish about this mattress? The Studio, Leesa’s budget-friendly offering, belies its economical price point with its exceptional performance. Comprising three layers of foam, this mattress cradles your body with remarkable support while effectively relieving pressure points. As someone who often shifts positions during sleep, typically ending up on my side, I appreciate the Studio’s excellent motion isolation and the balanced amount of plushness it provides, which suits my preferences perfectly.
Big Fig Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What distinguishes this mattress brand for you? As someone with a midsize build, I’ve often found that many products, especially furniture, fail to cater to bodies like mine, not to mention those of countless individuals larger than myself. Therefore, when I first learned about the Big Fig mattress, specifically designed for larger bodies, my curiosity was immediately piqued. Unlike other brands that sometimes exploit specific identities for profit (as observed during corporate America’s Women’s History Month campaigns), there has been a noticeable absence of offerings tailored to larger individuals in the market. So, was Big Fig genuinely addressing a need for people of size, rather than merely chasing profits? I was determined to find out.
What do you appreciate about this mattress? Beyond its explicit design and marketing for larger individuals, I adore everything about it! The mattress’s top layer is luxuriously plush and soft, while the core remains firm and responsive. Even the minute details, such as the tufts, are adorned with soft materials to ensure no uncomfortable encounters with hard buttons. For someone like me, who has grappled with issues like unstable edges, heat buildup, and mattresses that allowed me to sink too deeply, the Big Fig feels like the first time I’m experiencing the comfort of a high-quality mattress.
How would you describe the mattress’s firmness? As previously mentioned, this mattress is exceptionally firm. However, thanks to the top layer (and the added softness of the Big Fig mattress cover I acquired), it strikes a perfect balance between firm support and a touch of plushness that suits my preferences. While I’ve always favored a firmer mattress, I never truly associated this preference with my size until I experienced the Big Fig. Now, I understand that my preference aligns with the way a smaller person might appreciate the softness of their mattress— it’s all about relative comfort.
Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
What sets apart this mattress brand for you? The standout feature of Brentwood Home mattresses is the ingenious blend of memory foam and springs. This fusion provides an exceptional sleeping experience. The memory foam boasts cutting-edge cooling technology, ensuring year-round comfort. What truly captivates me is the presence of 2,697 individually pocketed coils, offering unrivaled support among hybrid mattresses in the market. Since its inception in 1987, Brentwood Home has consistently impressed me. Their commitment to handcrafting mattresses in a GOLS certified factory just outside Los Angeles, all in the USA, speaks volumes about their dedication to environmental and social responsibility.
What do you cherish about this mattress? This mattress feels like a slice of heaven, especially after a tiring day navigating the bustling streets of NYC. Comprising nine layers of premium materials, including cooling gel crafted with BioFoam®, GOTS certified organic wool and cotton, and nearly 2,700 coils, it exudes sheer opulence while delivering unparalleled support. Whether it’s for restful sleep, hours spent poring over manuscripts (my primary occupation!), working on a laptop, or simply lounging around with friends watching TV, this mattress proves its versatility time and again.
How would you describe the mattress’s firmness? The Brentwood Home mattress is officially classified as “medium soft” on their website, scoring a 4.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale. Initially, I was a bit skeptical of this rating, as I never considered myself a fan of softer beds. However, I stand corrected. This mattress strikes the perfect balance between plush comfort and steadfast support. If anything, it makes getting out of bed in the mornings a bit of a challenge!
Top mattress brand
- The DreamCloud Hybrid Mattress
- The Nectar Memory Foam Mattress
- Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress
- Birch Natural Mattress
- Floyd Mattress
- Casper Wave Hybrid Snow Mattress
- Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress
- WinkBed Luxury Firm Mattress
- Allswell Supreme Mattress
- Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress
- Serta Arctic Mattress
- Layla Hybrid Mattress
- Tuft & Needle Original Mattress
- Leesa Studio Mattress
- Big Fig Mattress
- Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress
FAQ
What are the best mattress brands?
Some of the top mattress brands include Helix Sleep, known for its hybrid mattresses, and Saatva, recognized for its luxury and cooling mattressesNectar and DreamCloud are also highly rated for their comfort and value.
What are good mattress brands?
Some reputable mattress brands include Tempur-Pedic, Saatva, Purple, and Sealy. These brands are known for their quality, comfort, and durability, making them popular choices among consumers seeking a good night’s sleep.
What mattress brands are made in the USA?
Several mattress brands are proudly manufactured in the USA, including Tempur-Pedic, Saatva, Purple, and Sealy. These brands are known for their quality, durability, and adherence to American manufacturing standards. Choosing one of these brands can support local industries while ensuring a well-crafted mattress.
What mattress brands have fiberglass?
Many mattress brands, including some well-known ones, use fiberglass as a fire retardant barrier within their mattresses. This material is typically located beneath the mattress cover and above the comfort layers. It’s important to be aware of this when handling or disposing of mattresses, as fiberglass can be irritating to the skin and respiratory system if it becomes airborne. Always check the manufacturer’s specifications or labels for information on the materials used in a mattress to determine if it contains fiberglass.
